Just as most cloth diapering people, I occasionally use disposable diapers. Since plastics and the chemicals found in disposable diapers are a concern for me, I do try to look for diapers that contain as few of those chemicals as possible.

Over the past few months, I’ve tried diapers such as, Nature Babycare, gDiapers with gRefills, Moltex OKO, Seventh Generation and PC Green. With every brand of these “eco” diapers, I found something lacking. Then I discovered Broody Chick diapers, the first 100% compostable diaper on the market. So far this diaper is my favourite disposable diaper.

When I received the diapers in the mail, I was very surprised by the packaging.  The diapers are sold in a cardboard box which I have never seen before.  I’m used to seeing disposable diapers in plastic or compostable bags.  The other thing that surprised me was the expiry date.  It makes me think that there’s something more natural in those diapers.  Unfortunately, I do not know all the details of the components making up this diaper.

What I like about this diaper:
1. Chlorine free
2. More “breathable” than diapers with plastic components
3. Fragrance free
4. Diaper and packaging are fully compostable
5. Created by a Canadian mom
6. The diaper does not smell as bad as other disposable diapers when dirty. Whenever my daughter wore disposable diapers in the past and peed in them, I thought she pooped the smell was so bad. I suspect that those who use disposables all the time are used to that smell, but to me that smell is quite strong.
7. No leaks even overnight.
8. No marketing on the diaper itself.

What I don’t like about this diaper:
1. The tabs are not stretchy. Even though I did get used to this, I still hope they will change those tabs.
2. Contains SAP (Super Absorbent Polymers)
3. Cost – I can’t find the diaper locally, so I have to pay to get it shipped from British Columbia

Overall, I really like this diaper and I even ended up using it for night-time for a bit because my daughter was such a heavy wetter at night that the soaking wet cloth diapers affected her sleep. Since last night, I’m back to cloth though because she wets her diapers a lot less now at night than she used to.

If you’re interested in purchasing this product, please check them out at the Ecobotts store. In case you decide to purchase from Ecobotts, please check their Facebook fan page for coupon codes.

I have not been paid to write this review. The Broody Chick diapers were purchased by me.

Lately, I’ve been asked a lot about PC Green Diapers.  These diapers are still relatively new and there isn’t a huge lot of information about them online.  So, I decided to tell you everything I know about them.

As I’ve written in a previous post, PC Green disposable diapers are chlorine and fragrance free.  Those of you who have had trouble finding other eco disposable diapers close to home, might have better luck finding these since PC Green diapers might be available in your supermarket store (owned by Loblaws).

What I do like about this diaper:

• Very stretchy tabs.  None of the other eco disposable diapers I’ve tried have tabs that stretchy.
• The diaper is quite a bit cheaper than other “green” diapers.  The regular price of PC Green diapers is $15.99 for 46 diapers in size 4.  Seventh Generation diapers are $17.99-19.99 for 30 diapers in the same size.  Also, you can sometimes see the PC Green diapers on special for $12.99.
• No rashes so far.  It does not promote healing of rashes very well though.  I found that bamboo cloth diapers with wool covers at night promote healing much better than the PC Green diapers even though cloth diapers get quite wet overnight.  I guess it’s not a surprise since cloth diapers do allow more airflow.  Also, bamboo is antimicrobial.

What I do NOT like about this diaper:

• SAP (Super Absorbent Polymer)
• Still has some plastics in it however, according to the manufacturer some of the plastic components were replaced with “revolutionary plant-based polymers”.
• Packaging is not biodegradable.
• It’s still a disposable that takes hundreds of years to decompose.  One of the few reasons why I don’t use disposables is that the thought of mountains of disposable diapers in the landfill really bothers me.
• I wasn’t impressed with what’s written about cloth diapers at the back of the packaging.  It might mislead people into believing that cloth diapers are made from pesticide sprayed cotton ONLY.  Trust me there’s LOTS of diapers out there (including my daughter’s) that are not.  I also wasn’t impressed with the mention of detergent as if tons of it were being used on diapers.  The truth is, most people use only 1/4 of the recommended amount of detergent to wash their diapers.  Also, a lot of people these days use front-loading washers which use quite a bit less water.

NOTE: These diapers do fit a bit bigger than SG diapers, so if you’re using SG diapers and your baby is almost outgrowing a size, PC Green diapers in the same size might still fit her/him well.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.  Just please keep in mind that I’m not an expert on disposable diapers – I normally cloth diaper only.

There’s a lot of information out there on the subject of how to get started with cloth diapering.  However, I haven’t seen a lot of good information for people who want to switch from disposables to cloth diapers.  I think those who switch from disposables need slightly different information than those who are planning to cloth diaper from the beginning.   So, let’s begin with the initial purchase of cloth diapers meant for those who are switching.

1. Buying Cloth Diapers

I recommend doing some research first to find out which type of diaper you might be interested in trying.  There’s a lot of styles out there and the prices vary from a couple of bucks to $200+ (I heard the most popular fitted diaper sold for at least that much at a Hyena Cart auction).  Just google some cloth diapers and you’ll find a ton of information.  Remember not to panic – you’re not buying a house after all :-)

If you’re switching from disposables to cloth diapers, I do NOT recommend buying a huge number of cloth diapers.  We had very few cloth diapers in the beginning and we started off slow.  The diapers we had back then were quite inexpensive compared to the popular brands.  I wasn’t a fan of those diapers, but thanks to my research, I decided to stick to cloth diapering because I knew there were better cloth diapers out there.  The first cloth diaper I bought myself was a bumGenius 2.0 pocket diaper.  I was amazed how nice the diaper looked compared to what I’ve seen before.  I couldn’t believe how easy this diaper was to use.  It’s as easy to put on as a disposable!  With this diaper though, you do have to stuff the pocket with an insert before use.  The AIO/AI2 diapers do not require any stuffing.

There’s a chart on The Diaper Jungle website that describes the four major types of cloth diapers used today.  Most people who want to switch to cloth, would probably be most comfortable using AIO/AI2 or pocket diapers.  Those diapers will cost you a bit though, but remember that you’d be paying a lot more for disposables in the long run.  I’ve probably spent no more than $400-500 on my 21 month-old daughter’s cloth diapers and I have A LOT of diapers.  I actually sold some of my used diapers online, so I probably got at least $150-180 back.  I’ll have more on the subject of selling used diapers in a later post.

So, once you’ve decided which type of cloth diapers you’d like to try, it’s time to find out where to buy those diapers.  If you want to go with mass produced diapers then your local baby store might have those.  If your local baby stores do not carry cloth diapers, then use a search engine to find online cloth diaper stores.   If you’d rather buy WAHM (Work At Home Mom)-made diapers then you might want to check out the following sites:

Hyena Cart

Etsy

Remember to try different diapers and not to buy too many the first time you purchase them.  I also recommend trying different doublers and/or inserts.  You want to find out which diapers and doublers/inserts work best for you.

In the next post, I’ll talk about washing cloth diapers.  It’s not as hard as you think!

As promised, here is the second part of “Eco-Friendly Disposable Diapers”.

3. gDiapers

When I first heard about gDiapers, I was very excited.  A diaper could be used as a disposable and a cloth diaper?  I simply had to have this diaper!

The diaper consists of a washable cotton little gPant (i.e. a cotton cover), a snap-in nylon liner and a plastic free gRefill or washable gCloth.  Besides the washable inserts that gDiapers makes, there are lots of WAHMs (Work at Home Moms) who make them as well in different shapes and sizes, and using different fabrics.

Unfortunately, my love with gDiapers was short lived.  I found that the inside snaps left marks on my baby’s skin.  I never used these for night-time since I didn’t think they’d be comfortable enough for that.  I wouldn’t want to wear something like that at night, so why would I put it on my baby?  I know a lot of parents out there do love these diapers for daytime AND night-time.   I suspect I’m just more picky than the average parent.  I think I’ve been spoiled by comfortable, soft and fluffy cloth diapers :-)

4. Seventh Generation

A lot of you have probably seen this light brown diaper.  In the past year or so, the popularity of Seventh Generation diapers has exploded.  I’ve seen it worn on a lot of babies, including celebrity babies.

The diaper is chlorine, fragrance and latex free.  It is NOT plastic free and it is NOT compostable.  I couldn’t believe that some people online say it’s “biodegradable”.  It’s not.  And please do NOT flush this diaper down the toilet.  I actually read somewhere that the diaper is flushable hahahaha.

What I did NOT like about this diaper:

• More SAP than Nature Babycare diapers
• Plastic instead of corn-based material
• VERY wide tabs which left marks on my baby’s legs
• Smaller than other disposable diapers in that size range.  My 30 lbs daughter is not going to be able to fit into size 4 for much longer, and the size 4 diaper is supposed to fit up to 37 lbs.

NOTE: The brown colour of this diaper is not naturally occurring.  The colour comes from the addition of pigments.

5. PC GREEN Disposable Diaper

Just like Seventh Generation (SG) diapers, the PC GREEN diapers are chlorine and fragrance free.  I found this diaper in a supermarket store, the same one that sells SG diapers.

What I liked about this diaper:

• VERY stretchy tabs.  None of the other eco-friendly diapers are like that.
• The diaper is quite a bit cheaper than other “green” diapers.  One PC GREEN diaper costs almost half as much as a Seventh Generation diaper.

What I did NOT like about this diaper:

• SAP
• Still has some plastic in it however, according to the manufacturer some of the plastic components were replaced with “revolutionary plant-based polymers.”

I must admit I like these diapers a lot more than SG diapers because of the stretchiness and better fit.

CONCLUSION:

None of the diapers I discussed in the two posts are perfect.  They still create huge amounts of waste whether compostable or not.  Also, none of the disposables seem comfortable enough.  I agree they’re a little thinner than my Northern Baby AIO (All-in-one) or AI2 (All-in-two) diapers, but they’re much less comfortable and not very healthy for my toddler.

NOTE: I recently found a great post about “green” disposable diapers.  I’ve never seen a mom do so much research on the subject as the author of the post you can find here.  After reading it, I was glad we haven’t been using disposables on a daily basis.

For those of you who don’t know, I use cloth diapers.  I make them as well :-)  When nothing goes wrong, I use them 100% of the time.  A handful of times I’ve had to deal with detergent residue thanks to switching detergents and/or using different washers.  I usually know it’s a detergent residue issue because our sensitive monkey gets a diaper rash.  Normally, she does not get one with cloth diapers, so I know what’s wrong immediately.

We recently moved and had no washer for 5 weeks.  During that time, I hand washed the diapers 3 times, my mom washed some in her washer a couple of times, and I went to the laundromat once.  The visit to the laundromat did not end well since my daughter ended up having a rash.  I suspect it was detergent or fabric softener residue in the washer from previous users.  So, whenever I need to re-wash the diapers, my daughter wears disposables (which isn’t very frequently).  Because I worry about what’s in disposables, I usually go with the “eco-friendly” ones.  Over the next couple of posts, I will write about the following disposable diapers:

• Nature Babycare
• Moltex OKO
• gDiapers
• Seventh Generation
• PC GREEN

1. Nature Babycare

This Swedish award-winning diaper is said to be more breathable because of a corn-based biodegradable outer film.  The Nature Babycare diaper and packaging are chlorine free and are potentially compostable (however you need specific conditions for that to occur).  The diaper does contain some SAP (Super Absorbent Polymer), but less than other disposables because of a unique, patented channel construction.

I chose this diaper because it has corn-based materials rather than plastic.  I’m also cautious about SAP, so the less of it, the better.  I do wish the diaper was a little softer on the outside and that the tabs could stick to anywhere on the diaper, but these are not major issues.

We only had one leak with this diaper and I think it might have been because the diaper has been getting a bit small.

2. Moltex OKO

Another compostable diaper made with corn-based material.  This one is made in Germany.  I only used one Moltex diaper which I received in a free trial pack.  The first thing I noticed was how much softer the diaper was as compared to the Nature Babycare diaper.  The diaper also seemed a little bigger, but it fit my daughter very well leaving no gaps.  She wore this sample diaper overnight and we had no leaks even though the diaper was quite heavy in the morning.

The one thing that I don’t like about this disposable is that it seems to have more SAP than Northern Babycare.

In part 2 of “Eco-Friendly Disposable Diapers”: My experience with gDiapers, Seventh Generation and PC GREEN diapers.