Over the past few months, I’ve tried diapers such as, Nature Babycare, gDiapers with gRefills, Moltex OKO, Seventh Generation and PC Green. With every brand of these “eco” diapers, I found something lacking. Then I discovered Broody Chick diapers, the first 100% compostable diaper on the market. So far this diaper is my favourite disposable diaper.

When I received the diapers in the mail, I was very surprised by the packaging.  The diapers are sold in a cardboard box which I have never seen before.  I’m used to seeing disposable diapers in plastic or compostable bags.  The other thing that surprised me was the expiry date.  It makes me think that there’s something more natural in those diapers.  Unfortunately, I do not know all the details of the components making up this diaper.

What I like about this diaper:
1. Chlorine free
2. More “breathable” than diapers with plastic components
3. Fragrance free
4. Diaper and packaging are fully compostable
5. Created by a Canadian mom
6. The diaper does not smell as bad as other disposable diapers when dirty. Whenever my daughter wore disposable diapers in the past and peed in them, I thought she pooped the smell was so bad. I suspect that those who use disposables all the time are used to that smell, but to me that smell is quite strong.
7. No leaks even overnight.
8. No marketing on the diaper itself.

What I don’t like about this diaper:
1. The tabs are not stretchy. Even though I did get used to this, I still hope they will change those tabs.
2. Contains SAP (Super Absorbent Polymers)
3. Cost – I can’t find the diaper locally, so I have to pay to get it shipped from British Columbia

Overall, I really like this diaper and I even ended up using it for night-time for a bit because my daughter was such a heavy wetter at night that the soaking wet cloth diapers affected her sleep. Since last night, I’m back to cloth though because she wets her diapers a lot less now at night than she used to.

If you’re interested in purchasing this product, please check them out at the Ecobotts store. In case you decide to purchase from Ecobotts, please check their Facebook fan page for coupon codes.

I have not been paid to write this review. The Broody Chick diapers were purchased by me.

We recently moved and had no washer for 5 weeks.  During that time, I hand washed the diapers 3 times, my mom washed some in her washer a couple of times, and I went to the laundromat once.  The visit to the laundromat did not end well since my daughter ended up having a rash.  I suspect it was detergent or fabric softener residue in the washer from previous users.  So, whenever I need to re-wash the diapers, my daughter wears disposables (which isn’t very frequently).  Because I worry about what’s in disposables, I usually go with the “eco-friendly” ones.  Over the next couple of posts, I will write about the following disposable diapers:

• Nature Babycare
• Moltex OKO
• gDiapers
• Seventh Generation
• PC GREEN

1. Nature Babycare

This Swedish award-winning diaper is said to be more breathable because of a corn-based biodegradable outer film.  The Nature Babycare diaper and packaging are chlorine free and are potentially compostable (however you need specific conditions for that to occur).  The diaper does contain some SAP (Super Absorbent Polymer), but less than other disposables because of a unique, patented channel construction.

I chose this diaper because it has corn-based materials rather than plastic.  I’m also cautious about SAP, so the less of it, the better.  I do wish the diaper was a little softer on the outside and that the tabs could stick to anywhere on the diaper, but these are not major issues.

We only had one leak with this diaper and I think it might have been because the diaper has been getting a bit small.

2. Moltex OKO

Another compostable diaper made with corn-based material.  This one is made in Germany.  I only used one Moltex diaper which I received in a free trial pack.  The first thing I noticed was how much softer the diaper was as compared to the Nature Babycare diaper.  The diaper also seemed a little bigger, but it fit my daughter very well leaving no gaps.  She wore this sample diaper overnight and we had no leaks even though the diaper was quite heavy in the morning.

The one thing that I don’t like about this disposable is that it seems to have more SAP than Northern Babycare.

In part 2 of “Eco-Friendly Disposable Diapers”: My experience with gDiapers, Seventh Generation and PC GREEN diapers.